August 7, 2022

I CAN simply detect Brian Wilson’s restrained anger on the state of the CalMac ferries and the dearth of any motion on the a part of our delegated authorities to alleviate the scenario whereas ships within the Port of Glasgow and new Turkish ships await supply (“Cynical calculations form ministers’ views on ferries). ”). fiasco, August 2).

Is it doable that a minimum of one of many Turkish boats might be commissioned earlier than the completion of the development of hull 802?

A number of ideas come up in reference to this newest article by Mr. Wilson. First, is there actually a hidden plan throughout the SNP authorities to depopulate the Western Isles? Small or no populations don’t want massive, costly ferries.

Then I remembered that the ferry corporations of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, together with David McBrain, used ships that might not all the time berth at sure ports. Ships had been anchored offshore, and quite a few public floating boats had been used to move items to and from shore.

The pufferfish are gone, however what if the island communities take issues into their very own arms and discover appropriate ships to offer their very own companies?

For instance, there are touchdown craft that may function from slipways or seashores as an alternative of piers obtainable on the market or constitution on dealer web sites.

I’m absolutely conscious of the impracticality of this concept, however will the specter of taking issues into their very own arms be sufficient for Caledonian Asset Administration Ltd (CMAL) and Jenny Gilruth to truly do one thing within the medium time period to beat this main catastrophe. ?

Or, as Brian Wilson says, our legislators in Holyrood are taking part in the lengthy sport and have determined to attend and use distraction techniques as wanted.

Ian Gray, Crofts.

Taking part in whereas the economic system of the Hebrides burns

CALMAC ferry watchers and lovers now not should make the lengthy journey to the Western Isles as they will head to Greenock and see how they’re tied up. It is also good for artists who now not want to attract from reminiscence or take a swiftly taken {photograph} – they’re actually nonetheless lifes.

Glen Sannox is at the moment in drydock, being sandblasted to reveal metal and repainted from keel to deck. She did not even flip the propeller in anger. Twenty tons of shells have been faraway from her hull to landfill, defying her inexperienced façade. It might be for the most effective that LNG gasoline was additionally not used, as now it has turned out to be much more poisonous than diesel gasoline.

MV Hebrides is again to maintain her firm whereas the Scottish authorities tinkers with the Hebridean economic system.

I wish to object to the “CalMac” banner affixed to all these ferry disasters. CalMac must be applauded for its means to handle historic property within the face of adversity. Regardless, they do a very good job.

The true villain on this article is CMAL, which owns and operates 35 ferry property and clearly would not stay as much as its firm identify.

Aren’t firm administrators who state on their web site that “we’re wholly owned by the Scottish Authorities and the Scottish Ministers are the only shareholders”.

One would assume that they, too, had been accountable to them?

Peter Wright, West Kilbride, Ayrshire.


DISCLAIMING current disrespectful remarks by Conservative and Unionist management candidate Liz Truss towards the Scottish First Minister, devolution standing in Scotland is now in severe jeopardy.

Whereas most Tory politicians will deny that is the case, actions communicate louder than phrases, and just lately the Conservative prime minister and his cupboard, together with management contenders, have taken quite a few actions that affirm their staunch hostility to devolution and the Scottish authorities. Authorities.

Merely sustaining the 2014 constitutional establishment is now not a actuality, because the views of the practically 75% of voters who voted in 1997 in favor of a major handover to Scotland are intentionally rejected by the celebration. Furthermore, it’s a celebration that represents the views of simply over 20% of Scottish voters and is led by a future Prime Minister elected by solely about 0.2% of the UK inhabitants.

Worse but, regardless of the devastating results Brexit has had on Scottish prosperity, and the plans and aspirations of lots of our companies and younger folks, Higher Collectively, with the assist and instigation of the London media moguls, will proceed to work collectively. to disclaim the folks of Scotland the independence referendum for which they’ve elected the Scottish authorities.

To not point out the whole consultant inadequacy of the UK’s archaic first-past-the-post voting system and the fixed embarrassment of the unelected second chamber. This isn’t a democracy.

Stan Grodynsky, Longnydry, East Lothian.


I AM, fairly frankly, outraged by the responses of a few of your correspondents to Liz Truss’ phrases about “ignoring” Nicola Sturgeon.

Ms. Sturgeon is an internationally revered politician with a few years of expertise as head of a competently functioning nationwide authorities; Miss Truss – what else however an indication of the whole political chapter of the Westminster system?

There’s not a single level in her profession that offers motive to consider that she is in any method appropriate to carry any place of duty, to not point out the place of prime minister.

And whereas it is exhausting to consider that the current sample of every successive prime minister worse than the final might go even additional, that is precisely what is going to occur if she is appointed.

For a nonentity like Mrs. Truss, to talk of “ignoring” a politician ten instances her personal means is audacity, plain and easy.

It’s mentioned that a few of your correspondents appear to contemplate such habits applicable.

I’m certain of 1 factor: if Ms. Truss turns into prime minister and tries to veto our holding of an independence referendum, she might be ignored.

Derrick McClure, Aberdeen.


With regard to your lead letter (“Coward has insulted us all. Now put together for much more causticity,” August 3), it’s curious how “lover of consideration” is such an insult, and “an empty vessel stuffed solely with ambition” is valued for journalistic perception and notion.

As your columnist Ian McWhirter mentioned elsewhere, politicians discuss all types of issues about one another, cope with it. That is to not say Ms. Sturgeon hasn’t spent her profession doing this kind of factor, and in recent times she’s gotten loads worse with the military of political strategists now obtainable to her.

Her ruthless chatter and discuss folks is orders of magnitude worse, and Miss Truss solely mentioned out loud what many people assume.

Miss Truss, to her credit score, thick-skinned sufficient to deal with this kind of factor. Ms Sturgeon and her supporters appear to be far much less so.

Victor Clements, Aberfeldy, Perthshire.

SNP contempt for SCOTLAND

JOHN Sweeney snorted and snorted that Liz Truss deriding Nicola Sturgeon as an “consideration lover” exhibits “contempt for Scotland”. How?

Miss Truss, after all, exhibits contempt for Miss Sturgeon, however since when did Miss Sturgeon embody the very idea of Scotland?

Will she quickly stand on the rostrum to proclaim: “I’m the state”?

The SNP usually determine with Scotland, seeing themselves as the one pure representatives of the nation.

To criticize them is to not criticize one among a variety of events and insurance policies, however to criticize Scotland itself, and due to this fact anybody who votes for one more celebration is a non-Scottish traitor or an evil foreigner.

The SNP will, after all, deny this: they usually protest that they’re multicultural, inclusive, and “civil”.

However this newest assertion by Mr Sweeney is one other case the place the masks has slipped and we see the vanity of their self-respect and the best way they belittle their countrymen.

If any celebration harbors “contempt for Scotland”, it’s the SNP.

Robert Fraser, Dundee.

Ossetian fortunate with rivals

Napoleon is credited with asking “I do know he is basic, however is he fortunate?”

Nicola Sturgeon might or will not be good – however gifted firstly with Boris Johnson after which in all chance with a girl who doesn’t a lot twirl (Ruth Marr, letters, August 4) as pirouettes, she actually comfortable.

Alan Carmichael, Glasgow.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.