October 2, 2022

I DON’T know what to do with Adam Tomkins laying out the explanation why he did not annoy Nicola Sturgeon (“There is a Option to Beat the Nationalists, However Do not Ignore Them,” The Herald, August 10). He pokes enjoyable at what he calls “muscular unionism”, the “British” who trolls him, and the “appeasement” he’s accused of. He goes on to listing issues that Liz Truss should not do below any circumstances if she is elected prime minister. It is a lot better, he says, to be the great guys and play the lengthy sport.

Assist for independence might not have elevated, it is true, but it surely hasn’t decreased both. The cut up between nationalists and commerce unions has taken root, and the longer it persists, the deeper the rut will probably be and the tougher will probably be to get out of it. Then intelligence is not going to remedy the issue.

I believe the UK authorities must be extra assertive in its position in Scotland, as it’s with devolved administrations and metropolis mayors in England. You keep away from accusations of intimidation by making use of the identical guidelines to your self as to decentralized governments. So, for instance, we must always have the identical requirements of transparency, accounting and budgeting in all the things, in addition to frequent guidelines and sanctions for civil servants, a standard understanding of the position of the courts in the necessity to stay unbiased and common respect. what’s inside your competence and what’s not.

I am all for being robust on politicians who waste time and our cash on points they do not have the general public’s permission for. Nicola Sturgeon does no matter she likes and nobody dares to the touch her. If we beat across the bush, it can solely worsen. Combating any abuse of energy isn’t “muscle tissues”, it is simply frequent sense. Not fixing them is absolutely “appeasement”. Sure, the phrase has connotations, but it surely nonetheless precisely describes noticed conduct, and that is what Professor Tomkins does, whether or not he sees it or not.

It’s this conduct that ensures that the so-called pro-union events by no means break by, and the nicer and saner they’re, the much less probability that something will ever change. Alastair Darling was a great man, however nearly threw him out in 2014. It was Gordon Brown who banged his fist and made folks sit down and pay attention, and received the day when all the things appeared to be misplaced. Miss Truss, too, should train her authority if we’re ever to unravel these issues.

Victor Clements, Aberfeldy.


An IAIN Dale interview with Nicola Sturgeon (“Sturgeon ‘might not lead SNP to subsequent Holyrood election'”, The Herald, August 11) acquired extra consideration than it deserves. It was a Fringe present, not a severe political interview. There was a large group of SNPs within the viewers who loudly expressed their admiration for his or her chief, and Mr. Dale bombarded Ms. Sturgeon with moderately pleasant questions. What a pity he did not ask a few of her solutions. For instance, when Mrs. Sturgeon said that an insult to her was an insult to Scotland, he might gently trace that the identification of a with nation and vice versa is a twentieth century relic that we’ve determined to depart behind.

Ms Sturgeon stated an unbiased Scotland would belong to the Widespread Journey Space together with the UK and Eire. Nonetheless, she additionally needs Scotland’s immigration coverage to be very completely different from Britain’s. How will it work? This isn’t true. However it was a query that wanted to be requested. As for Sturgeon/SNP’s common grievance that they may do way more if that they had extra borrowing energy, Mr. Dale might ask who she expects to behave as her surety, her lender of final resort. . The reply is, in fact, the Financial institution of England. However why would the Financial institution of England act as a guarantor for loans granted by a financially irresponsible administration whose observe report in finance and spending taxpayer cash is already extremely doubtful?

Mr. Dale’s present was a missed alternative. However then the “present” was what it was, and Ms. Sturgeon made it potential for her stall to be exhibited with out the inconvenience of getting to elucidate how its elements would work.

Jill Stephenson, Edinburgh.

• I WANT independence, however I am livid that our first minister parades on the Edinburgh festivals. She is not any higher than Boris Johnson.

The prime minister and first minister are AWOL within the midst of a number of crises.

For my part, the overseas secretary did effectively throughout Covid, however she ought to be strapped to her desk and banging on the heads of the Kalmak chiefs and her transport minister to get the ferry service to the islands up and operating. Messing round at festivals does nothing however elevate her private profile, which does not assist the islanders get a pint of milk.

I need to go on trip to the Western Isles, however not whereas this carnage is happening.

Ms. Sturgeon, should you’d moderately seem in Vogue and make your mark on the Edinburgh Pageant, step apart and let another person take us to the Promised Land of Independence.

IB. Archibald, Edinburgh.


My current letter (August 8) describing Brexit as an English invention voted for by English prejudices in an outdated authorized system prompted two criticisms.

First, the declare that the SNP ought to have voted for Theresa Could’s delicate Brexit as an alternative of letting Boris Johnson run amok. Scotland needed and nonetheless does not need any type of Brexit, and the SNP rightly rejected any such proposal.

Secondly, we merely have to just accept the present system of presidency, which leaves us with an undemocratic parliament steeped in English traditions, with an unelected chamber and big English weight. Solely the nationalist events need to change this (however not essentially in such a means that we stay the UK, as we wish).

Westminster is named the mom of all parliaments, however exterior of England it’s extra like a mother-in-law.

JB. Drummond, Kilmarnock.


I FOUND myself beginning to surprise if 2014 was erased from all information.

Arthur Greenan’s letter (dated 11 August) reveals that he’s completely satisfied to cite Professor John P. Waterproof coat and his 1974 speech on independence: “offered it’s the desire of the Scottish folks”. He then quotes Donald Dewar on Could 21, 1997 in Hansard: “I’ve to be the final to problem the sovereignty of the folks in the event that they need to go for independence, I see no purpose why they should not.”

Please appropriate me if I am incorrect, however my impression is {that a} referendum held solely eight years in the past happy each of those claims, and the outcome was a powerful rejection of independence by the vast majority of the folks of Scotland.

I observe that “democracy” is the brand new grievance, and so I am guessing there’s now hypothesis that the 2014 referendum was by some means not democratic.

This is a thought: In protection of true democracy, and on the grounds that Scotland’s withdrawal from the Union would have an effect on 4 nations, it could definitely be extra “democratic” if all 4 of those nations had been allowed to vote for a potential break. from this union?

Lastly, I totally agree with all of the supporters of Ruth Marr and her household (Letters, August 11). There is no such thing as a place for swearing wherever, and I completely defend her proper to opinion and freedom of speech.

John Kennedy, Sterling.

• I WANT to thank your correspondents for his or her responses to my letter of August ninth, however I have to level out to Robin Johnston that harsh criticism is one factor, insults one other, and I totally endorse the feedback made by Craig Wishart and R. Russell concerning abuse. Smith.

I used to be dismayed by Mr. Johnston’s assertion that I used to be at all times mentioning “the alleged defects of all issues English or Westminster”; he’s proper about Westminster, however utterly incorrect about my angle in direction of England, a rustic which I respect and love very a lot. My household is from Shropshire, I’ve lots of English family members and infrequently vacation in England – in truth, my final vacation just a few months in the past was a raucous journey to Blackpool with my daughters and grandchildren. And I can guarantee Mr. Johnston that, as nasty as it’s, I’ll climate the warmth and haven’t any intention of leaving the kitchen.

Ruth Marr, Sterling.

Learn extra: Vitality-rich Scotland pays the worth for EU membership

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.